Assisted Suicide would mean death for this country and its most vulnerable members

A short blog in response to the parliamentary question of Baroness Meacher, an assisted suicide advocate, who wishes the government to legalise the practice.

Baroness Meacher is on the move again.

The peer, who is also Chair of the organisation ‘Dignity in Dying’, recently put forward the parliamentary question: “To ask Her Majesty’s Government whether they have any plans to legalise assisted dying for terminally ill capacitous adults, with appropriate safeguards.”


The succinct reply included the words “the short Answer to the Question is no”.
Baroness Meacher was also reminded that the House of Commons voted against the last Assisted Suicide Bill by 330 to 118. But something which could have also been pointed out is that there is no such thing as ‘appropriate safeguards’.

Clear evidence of this came to light just last week. It was found that a British psychiatrist was instrumental in sending 6 dementia patients, who could not be deemed to be ‘mentally capacitous’ to their deaths at assisted suicide clinics in Switzerland. Here was a serious abuse of the law… in a country where assisted suicide is still illegal!


Before starting at Life I worked in a solicitor’s office for a while. I remember being asked to help out with the administration in a case involving two dementia patients who changed their will in their last years and signed away a large part of their estate while they were, according to medical notes and according to the firm I worked for, not in the right frame of mind to do so. The result was that the family split apart. One half of the family felt severely aggrieved as they felt that the house of their elderly parents had been unfairly taken away from them, while the other half argued that their parents were of sound mind when they changed their will.


This is an example of the heartache which can be involved when the estate of vulnerable people is at stake… but multiply that heartache by a thousand in order to imagine what would happen if assisted suicide were to be made legal. An estate being taken away from someone is one thing, but the very life of a loved one is an entirely different matter.

Baroness Meacher would undoubtedly argue that abuses, of the kind carried out by the psychiatrist, would only happen rarely.

The first thing is that even one vulnerable patient’s life is a good enough reason not to introduce an Assisted Suicide law. To give a similar example, I was at one stage Scotland’s (self-proclaimed) greatest advocate of introducing wolves back into the Scottish wild. I was eventually persuaded against the idea, however, by the notion that if even one innocent human being was mauled to death by a hungry pack of wolves unnecessarily, it would make the re-introduction of wolves the wrong decision.


With an assisted suicide law though, the dangers would be far greater than if many thousands of wolves were to be let loose across the moors and valleys of Scotland! Only a small percentage of people go camping in the wild. But practically every person goes through the healthcare system in the UK and even if they are fortunate enough not to find themselves at the mercy of others, it is very likely that their loved ones will.

Indeed, in this vein, one of the slides of the Euthanasia presentation which we deliver in schools reads “What is worse: Not to kill those who want to die? Or to kill those who do not want to die?”. Undoubtedly it is worse to kill those who do not want to die. And undoubtedly the introduction of an Assisted Suicide law would lead to many being killed who do not want to die.



The experience of other countries and states where Assisted Suicide has been legalised abundantly confirms this. Moreover, the experience of other countries is that when Assisted Suicide laws are introduced, the quality and quantity of palliative care decreases. In fact, there have been cases where patients have been offered suicide as a ‘treatment’ option when they haven’t asked for it instead of viable medical treatment which would save their lives.



Much more could be said about the dangers of legalising assisted suicide, but I will end with this question: To ask euthanasia advocates when they will take into account the great body of evidence which shows that assisted suicide leads only to grave abuses and the devaluing of human life?


Please note: We reserve the right to delete comments that are antagonistic, offensive, or off-topic. If in doubt, read our comments policy.

3 people are talking about Assisted Suicide would mean death for this country and its most vulnerable members

  1. Sarah Ashmore says:

    Your arguments against assisted suicide and totally correct. Such legislation would truly involve the loss of illimitable human lives, the old being human also, as some prefer not to recognize. You discuss a family broken apart by suspicions related to real estate gains. It must be said that it is far from a case of that only families get muddled about what or who they care for the most. There is presently operational in Britain and elsewhere an absolutely massive crime syndicate, involving British and foreign property speculators of myriad shades and hues who act against the last to corrupt/bribe countless thousands of British people, and also newcomers to GB, to prey upon the old and vulnerable to force them out of their privately owned and even rented (for later purchase) abodes. The syndicates have a system of crime which I myself have the misfortune to be very familiar with because the culprits forced my own now deceased Mum from her home, and targeted her into silence, every single day in nursing home care, so horrifically that I hourly have to force the thoughts of their cruelty from my mind. The criminals, expert in lock-picking and seduction, either trespass or inveigle trust from their victims to then use brutal surreptitious methods to deprive them of health, mobility, sanity, confidence, and a safe home. The culprits often use identity supplanting crimes, through which the isolated victim is not noticed as being lost to the world. crime network incudes person employed in health and home care situations, along with anyone who can get at private financial and other data about people who could be forced from their homes. They even steal victim's address books to decide who to prey up then. My own ID had been, and still is being, used for harm, whilst there seems to chance of my moving to dwell in any place at which culprits of crime have not set the property up to use illegal surveillance and even gang stalking, until they can be rid of me. I am 67 years of old, and the multi-billion £s property stealing syndicate all want me not to send e-mails such as this. But, I must state that, the country is in no fit state vis a vis organized crime targeting o.a.p.s for any sort of assisted suicide to become law. In her nursing home, the staff demanded that she ask to die, and repeatedly expected to deny her care, whilst lying to GPs completely about Mum's situation and health.

  2. Peter Sullivan says:

    Dear Ms Ashmore,

    I'm really sorry to hear about your late mother and how she was treated in her final years. I tried to find an organisation who may be able to help and came across the organisation 'Action on Elder Abuse' ( ). They have a helpline on their website and it looks like they may be able to help in some way.

    Wishing you all the best in the way ahead with this.

    Kind regards,


    1. Disney says:

      A simple and ineilltgent point, well made. Thanks!

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.